Now baking in Tustin

We Don't Make Bagels.
We Make Them Every Morning

Hand-rolled, boiled, and baked before dawn — the way bagels should be. From our kitchen on 17th Street to your plate, every bite carries the discipline of craft.

Explore Our Menu Call Us

Baked Before Sunrise

Every single day, rain or shine

Since Day One

4 AM

Daily bake start

Loved Locally

100+

Varieties & combos

Fresh Promise

Same Day

Only what we bake today

Scroll

Craft Isn't a Marketing Word
Here — It's a Schedule

While other bakeries treat bagels as an afterthought, we treat them as the main event. Every batch starts at 4 AM with ingredients we can name and techniques we've refused to shortcut.

Located on 17th Street in Tustin, 5th Ave Bagelry is where the neighborhood comes for bagels that actually taste like bagels — dense, chewy, properly boiled, and finished in a hot oven. No freeze-thaw. No compromises.

Hand-Rolled

Every single bagel

Boiled & Baked

Traditional method

Same Day

Nothing old on the shelf

Local First

Tustin's own bakery

What We Make

From classic everything to seasonal specials — every item on our menu starts with a fresh batch.

Signature Bagels

Plain, sesame, poppy, everything, onion, cinnamon raisin — and rotating seasonal flavors that keep our regulars guessing.

Bagel Sandwiches

Lox and cream cheese, breakfast sandwiches with local eggs, and hearty lunch options built on freshly sliced bagels.

Coffee & Drinks

Proper coffee to pair with your bagel — espresso, drip, cold brew, and specialty drinks made with care.

Platters & Catering

Office meetings, weekend brunches, family gatherings — we assemble platters that make any occasion feel considered.

Spreads & Toppings

House-made cream cheeses, artisan butter, and specialty spreads that elevate a simple bagel into a proper meal.

Fresh Each Morning

What's on the menu today was in the oven before most people woke up. That's not a guarantee — it's just how we operate.

Ask About Our Full Menu

When to Find Us
Before We Sell Out

Monday – Friday 5:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Saturday 5:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Sunday 6:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Popular items sell out by noon — come early.

Call Us

(657) 600-8595

5thavebagelrytustin@gmail.com

Find Us in
the Heart of Tustin

17351 17th St

Tustin, CA 92780

Free street parking available

What Tustin Says

We don't need to chase reviews — our regulars do the talking for us.

"The bagels here are unlike anything I've had at chain bakeries. You can taste the difference that real craft makes — chewy, flavorful, and always fresh."

Maria S.

Tustin resident

"I stop by every Saturday morning before it gets busy. The lox bagel sandwich is worth the drive from anywhere in Orange County. Best in the area, hands down."

James T.

Weekly regular

"We ordered a platter for our office brunch and everyone was impressed. The team here takes genuine pride in what they do — it shows in every bite."

Sarah L.

Catering order

Get in Touch

Whether you want to place a catering order, ask about our daily specials, or just say hello — we're here. Reach out by phone, email, or stop by the shop.

Address

17351 17th St, Tustin, CA 92780

Phone

(657) 600-8595

5thavebagelrytustin@gmail.com

Send Us a Message

We'll get back to you within one business day.

Name

Phone (optional)

Subject

Message

Message Sent!

Thanks for reaching out. We'll get back to you shortly.

Fresh Bagels Don't Wait.
Neither Should You.

Stop by 17351 17th St in Tustin, or call us to place your order. We're open every morning — but the good stuff doesn't last till noon.

(657) 600-8595 View Menu

Is this your business?This is my business

We Don't Make Bagels. We Make Them Every Morning

Craft Isn't a Marketing Word Here — It's a Schedule